Arun Jaitley A Failed Finance Minister


GST Payer
watch_later 3 years, 4 months ago

Arun Jaitley a failed finance minister

What you think of Arun Jaitley?

I think he has completely failed in his role as a finance minister. They could have better appointed someone good.

Why I think Arun Jaitley failed?

Let us have a look at different events that took place during his tenure.

  1. Demonetisation
  2. GST
  3. Cash transactions

These are 2 big events that took place during his tenure.

Do you really think both of these handled in a democratic way?

I do not think so!!!

I have my own reasons to blame and doubt qualification of Arun Jaitley for his position.

Now coming to each of above events.

Demonetization has given no fruitful results to public, government, in fact it helped few to generate more black money.

People died in ATM/Bank lines, well that is debatable. But what results we got from demonetization.

They(government) say it will have long term benefits. At least list them down for public to understand.

He has never spoken on any matter. He has made things more complicated. He has done more damage to business community.

Business is down, people are confused and seems finance ministry too is confused.

Will you vote for Modi in 2019?

My answer will be no, if I have a better option. If congress change its mind and instead of Rahul Gandhi, brings another face, believe me Modi will have tough time.

Government has to take responsibility for all this nonsense and entire cabinet of Modi government has completely failed. Be it home ministry (killing of CRPF), be it Railway ministry (multiple train accidents), be it education ministry (universities are converted to election battle grounds), be it finance ministry (worst of all).

People are silent that does not mean they are idiot.

Gujus are mostly business owners in India, let us see what happens in Gujarat election.

6 Answers

Manohar Battula watch_later 3 years, 3 months ago
arrow_drop_up
1
arrow_drop_down

One should acknowledge the courage to take such decisions,If not better than past governments they are not bad either,

Atleast there is a ray of hope with this government they are moving ahead inspite of resistance from all parties,reason best known to all of us.

No one would have questioned the government if they had not taken these reforms they would have let it go.

GST everyone acknowledges that entire world has to migrate to.Its is intentented to plug the loopholes.

Businesses should learn to be a part of economy by being responsible,Compliance and with improvement of tax to GDP ratio would lessen the tax burden of honest tax payers.

  • chatComments
    Agree to your points. But you see entire Modi government is present in Gujarat right now. Modi and team has good plans agreed but implementation is poor which needs to be improved. - GST Payer

Vijay Viatla watch_later 3 years, 4 months ago
arrow_drop_up
1
arrow_drop_down

People will support when there is cash rotation & employment. Doesn't matter as long as Indirect Taxes (GST) are paid and the GDP is going up.

This government is helping big boys (Patajali, Ambanis, Adanis, Dhamanis etc) by killing all small players.

Small players mostly depends on Cash which Modi Govt, robbed. I am not sure whether any other govt can fix this as this is an irreversible mistake which no educated man will encourage.

Looks good in Movies but disaster in reality

  • chatComments
    They killed cash economy. - GST Payer
    How justified it s to support the cash transactions,dont you feel that everyone needs to be a part of formal economy? - Manohar Battula

anonymous user watch_later 3 years, 4 months ago
arrow_drop_up
1
arrow_drop_down

This government failed, the entire cabinet failed.

Did Modi fail?

The decision taken by this government (economical) are most complicated that any government has taken in recent past.

We witnessed Manmohan Singh era, it was a complete disaster. But haters will say current government has implemented policies of congress government.

Well, you need to have the courage to implement these steps.

Demonetization is not a new concept, it was discussed even at the time of Indira Gandhi, but even she could not do it due to fear of losing an election.

Modi government is doing right things at right time.

It is public which needs to support.

  • chatComments
    MODI ALSO FAIL - DEBASIS KARFA
    Whether demonitization or GST, the implementation must take care of common people small traders. But this is not the case. By all their actions and inactions till now this govt has shown that they are a care taker of big companies who are political donors to BJP. - Mohammad Anwar Zahoor

Surendra surana watch_later 3 years, 4 months ago
arrow_drop_up
0
arrow_drop_down

With the level of corruption we have and bureaucrats being employed based on cast rather than competency. This will be the out come when reforms and new systems are introduced, who ever may be the Finance Minister.

  • chatComments

Rahul Rai watch_later 3 years, 4 months ago
arrow_drop_up
0
arrow_drop_down

Yes Jaitley is a disaster. Why Modi is not giving a chance to Subramanian Swamy?

He is a better person with some logic too.

He can be a better finance minister than Arun Jaitley at any given point of time.

  • chatComments
    Swamy is a hit and run case, cannot be trusted. - GST Payer
    let us focus on our business ,if we would have done that there wouldnt have any reason to crib.Hum toh hamara business nahi sambhal sakte ,desh ko chalane ki baat karte hain . - Manohar Battula

anonymous user watch_later 3 years, 4 months ago
arrow_drop_up
0
arrow_drop_down

This Yeshwant Sinha is a past bureaucrat and we know what they are good at.

He did not get any portfolio or position in government so throwing stones.

Arun Jaitley is useless but do not blame Modi for anything. He alone cannot take care of everything.

Do you have any other person in BJP who can be replaced with him?

  • chatComments
    Why not replace BJP itself? - Mohammad Anwar Zahoor
    you have tolerated congress till now,give chance to BJP for atleast soe years,its too early to conclude,Non BJP means many more years of doom for sure - Manohar Battula
Did Not get Answer?

Join the largest Taxation Q&A platform on internet and ASK YOUR OWN question.

Ask your Question

You need to be logged in to answer.

Ask Question